About this Author
Dr. Mark Goulston, a psychiatrist and executive coach, authored "PTSD for Dummies." Dr. Diana Hendel, a former CEO of Long Beach Memorial Medical Center and Miller Children's and Women's Hospital, wrote "Responsible: A Memoir."
2020
Health, Fitness & Dieting
Psychology & Mental Health
10:42 Min
Conclusion
7 Key Points
Conclusion
Healthcare workers face extreme stress and risk of PTSD from COVID-19, battling under harsh conditions with inadequate support. Effective treatment and support systems are crucial, including therapy, community support, and workplace wellness to help manage and recover from the mental toll.
Abstract
In "Why Cope When You Can Heal," healthcare workers' profound struggles during the COVID-19 pandemic are explored, revealing the severe mental toll and potential for PTSD from their warlike conditions in under-equipped and overwhelmed settings. The book, authored by Dr. Mark Goulston, a psychiatrist and executive coach, and Dr. Diana Hendel, a former hospital CEO, emphasizes the crucial role of empathy, support, and effective mental health strategies, including therapies like CBT and EMDR, for recovery. It advocates redefining PTSD as a mental injury rather than a disorder, highlighting the need for societal shifts in understanding and addressing trauma.
Key Points
Summary
Healthcare workers battle COVID-19 in “warlike” conditions.
Healthcare workers have faced harrowing conditions during the pandemic, dealing with unprecedented uncertainty and death. They've worked in under-equipped hospitals and even used soccer fields and ice cream trucks as makeshift facilities. By June 2020, over 450,000 healthcare workers worldwide were reported infected.
In addition to these challenges, healthcare workers have struggled with the lack of a coordinated national response and deep political divisions in the U.S. While some Americans pushed to reopen the economy, others emphasized the importance of saving lives and maintaining social distance. Without adequate support, America's healthcare workers have continued to care for a relentless stream of patients and cope with high stress levels alone.
COVID-19 pandemic can cause PTSD.
In 2020, The New York Times reported on a young nurse who was the sole person in the room with a 75-year-old man dying of COVID-19. She held his hand and assisted him in video calling his relatives outside the room. Many healthcare workers have faced similar heart-wrenching scenarios during the pandemic. They have to maintain a brave front, dealing with the fear of contracting the virus and the stress of seeing patients die with professional calmness.
Healthcare workers also struggle with the fear of the unknown, as COVID-19 brought many uncertainties. The end of the pandemic was not in sight, and some people responded to health guidelines with disbelief and anger, complicating the workers' tasks. There is also a social stigma attached to working with COVID-19 patients, making it hard for workers to connect with family and friends who don't understand their daily challenges. They often feel a deep sense of responsibility and guilt when they can't save a patient, leading to feelings of helplessness.
Being unable to physically comfort dying patients due to health restrictions conflicts with their values, causing what is known as moral injury—a condition also experienced by soldiers in war. Continuous exposure to such stress without the chance to recover can leave healthcare workers at high risk of developing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
The Mental Strain on Healthcare Workers
Healthcare workers face incredibly stressful jobs, constantly pressured to save lives and cope with the sadness of sometimes failing. Those on the front lines have high rates of suicide and burnout.
Pandemics historically take a heavy mental toll on healthcare workers. For instance, after the 2003 SARS outbreak, Toronto's healthcare workers showed much higher levels of post-traumatic stress. A study in 2020 in JAMA Network Open revealed that 72% of healthcare workers across more than 30 hospitals in China felt distressed, half suffered from anxiety and depression, and over a third had trouble sleeping. Many of these workers are likely to experience PTSD from their COVID-19 experiences.
PTSD: Challenges and Solutions
PTSD occurs when people go through or see something extremely scary or shocking. While some with PTSD might seem fine socially, they may struggle with severe symptoms like feeling detached, overly alert, experiencing flashbacks, feeling numb, having unwanted thoughts, and avoiding certain situations. PTSD results from experiencing trauma that makes individuals feel powerless and scared.
Often, people with PTSD face unfair judgment from society. Others may criticize them for not recovering quickly and call them "unpredictable" or "moody." Health experts can help reduce this stigma by referring to PTSD as a "mental injury" instead of a "mental disorder." This change in language helps acknowledge that the condition is due to external trauma, not an internal disorder.
Study the 12 phases of PTSD to grasp trauma's mental impact.
People experience traumatic events through a series of 12 emotional phases:
Address pain with suitable treatment, don't conceal it.
People may think someone with PTSD is recovering if they seem happy, but often they are hiding their pain. Healing involves confronting and processing unresolved emotions from traumatic events. Empathy from others, whether they relate to what you're feeling ("surgical empathy") or they express understanding of your struggle ("clinical empathy"), is crucial in healing.
There are various PTSD treatments to consider:
Body-based treatments are also an option:
Consider medication if suggested by your healthcare provider, as it can help with PTSD and related issues like depression or anxiety.
Work towards healing from trauma.
If you're dealing with PTSD, here are some practical steps to help in your recovery:
Leaders should provide hope, empathy, and team unity.
If you're leading during tough times, it's crucial to inspire hope and recognize everyone's feelings and experiences. Show empathy and provide trauma-informed support. Be present and listen to your team as they share their feelings about traumatic events, even if their words make you uncomfortable. Communicate clearly, share timely and accurate information, reduce uncertainty, and make sure everyone understands the organization's plans.
PTSD isn't a guaranteed outcome of trauma. As a leader, you can lessen the uncertainty and put safety first. Remind your team that you are all in this together.
Share: