Investing with Keynes

Justyn Walsh

Investing with Keynes
/

About this Author

Justyn Walsh leads BridgeLane Agriculture Partners as CEO, bringing experience from his past roles as a corporate lawyer and investment banker. His diverse background likely enhances the firm's strategic vision and ability to pilot the complexities of asset management in the agricultural sector.

First Edition: 2021

Category: Business & Money

Sub-Category: Finance

12:00 Min

Conclusion

6 Key Points


Conclusion

Transform your approach to investing by focusing on intrinsic value and practicing patience. Adopt careful analysis and maintain a concentrated portfolio. Remember to stay calm and composed amid market fluctuations. These timeless lessons can guide you toward lasting success in investing.

Abstract

John Maynard Keynes, a renowned economist, was also a successful investor, leaving behind a substantial fortune upon his death. Keynes's investing journey was marked by both triumphs and failures, from pioneering value investing to experiencing setbacks in the late 1920s. His investment principles, articulated in six key rules, emphasize focusing on intrinsic stock value, maintaining a margin of safety, and exercising independent judgment. Despite initial losses, Keynes's economic theories evolved, influenced by his investment experiences, leading to a balanced approach of equanimity and patience in decision-making. Justyn Walsh's analysis of Keynes's investment strategies highlights the enduring relevance of value investing principles, offering insights beyond Warren Buffett's famed approach.

Key Points

  • Shifting from momentum to value investing, he stressed intrinsic value and safety margins.
  • Independent judgment, steadfast holding, and concentrated portfolios were his key strategies.
  • Prioritize resilience and decisive action during market turmoil.
  • Learning from mistakes, he and Buffett emphasized staying true to beliefs and keeping calm.
  • Their experiences teach critical thinking, patience, and disciplined investing.
  • Valuable lessons from Keynes and Buffett highlight the importance of long-term strategies.

Summary

Keynes: revolutionary economist, highly successful investor.
John Maynard Keynes, renowned for rescuing the world from the Great Depression, also found success as an investor. Upon his death in 1946, he left behind a fortune worth GBP 480,000, approximately $30 million today. While his books earned him a decent income, most of his wealth stemmed from savvy investments. Keynes pioneered value investing, a practical approach followed by figures like Warren Buffett. He was a rare economist who applied his theories to real-world success.
Born in 1883 in Cambridge, England, Keynes studied mathematics and classics at Cambridge University. Initially uninterested in money, he pursued civil service but returned to academia due to boredom. Leading the "Bloomsberries" at Cambridge, known for their unconventional lifestyles, Keynes developed a contrarian streak. Despite lacking formal qualifications, he began teaching economics at King's College in 1909 and became editor of the Economic Journal in 1911. The experience of World War I deeply impacted Keynes, resulting in the loss of many close friends.
Keynes' Blunt Diplomacy
Even as he aged, Keynes was known for his sharp tongue, described as "too offensive for words" by an ambassador in 1917. This reputation persisted during negotiations for the postwar Treaty of Versailles. Serving as economic adviser to the British delegation, he vehemently warned against imposing punitive sanctions on Germany, fearing destabilization in Europe. In 1919, as treaty talks approached completion, Keynes resigned in protest. His influential book, "The Economic Consequences of the Peace," published in December 1919, criticized the onerous agreement and targeted figures like Clemenceau, Wilson (whom he likened to a "blind and deaf Don Quixote"), and fellow Briton David Lloyd George.
Wealth from Innovating Value Investment.
Keynes's willingness to challenge the norm made him unpopular but served him well. As an economist, he defied the establishment, creating a dominant economic theory. Similarly, as an investor, going against the grain brought him wealth.

In 1919, Keynes entered currency trading, profiting from market volatility without a gold standard. He quickly earned GBP 6,000 (about $375,000 today). Encouraged, he launched a trading business with GBP 30,000 in 1920. Despite setbacks, he rebuilt his stake to GBP 21,000 by 1922.However, in 1925, Winston Churchill's reinstatement of the gold standard reduced currency opportunities. Keynes criticized this, foreseeing negative impacts on Britain's exports. He then shifted to stock trading, advocating for compound interest and common stock investment.

Keynes' six investing rules.

Keynes, a famous economist, tried a risky investing strategy called "credit cycle investing," now known as "momentum investing." Instead of carefully studying companies, he aimed to buy low and sell high. Confident in his skills, he thought he could time the market. But his luck turned sour in the late 1920s. His investments in commodities like rubber, corn, cotton, and tin tanked. Even his stock in Austin Motor Company crashed. By 1930, his portfolio had 80% plunged from GBP 44,000 to just GBP 8,000, leaving him almost broke. His overconfidence and reliance on his own stock-picking abilities led to his downfall.

These financial setbacks influenced Keynes's groundbreaking economic philosophy. Classical economics, which posited market efficiency and rational prices, failed to account for the realities Keynes experienced. The onset of the Great Depression reinforced his belief that markets didn't always self-correct. He famously remarked, "In the long run, we are all dead," rejecting the notion that economic troubles would automatically resolve over time.
Keynes' Economic Evolution

In formulating his groundbreaking economic theory, Keynes feared that inaction would bolster the rise of communist and fascist movements, which he viewed as flawed alternatives to capitalism. He also criticized the laissez-faire approach of free market economists, believing it glorified undesirable traits like "avarice and usury and precaution." Keynes argued against waiting for the invisible hand to rectify capitalism, advocating instead for substantial government spending to stimulate capitalist economies. The economic collapse of the late 1920s not only influenced Keynes's economic views but also altered his investment strategy. Transitioning from devising to value investing, he adopted fundamental analysis and a buy-and-hold approach, finding success by adhering to six key rules.
Rule One: "Focus on the estimated intrinsic value of a stock."

Following a failed attempt at "momentum investing," Keynes shifted his focus to become a dedicated "value investor" and bargain hunter. He believed that since markets are often irrational, the best strategy was to identify stocks undervalued by the market. Keynes sought stocks with "intrinsic value" greater than their market-assigned value.

Despite the "efficient market theory" suggesting that stock prices reflect all available information, Keynes recognized that sometimes market prices diverged from a stock's true value, presenting opportunities. This approach extended beyond investing to his personal life. Known for his frugality, Keynes once acquired a Cezanne painting at auction for the modest price of GBP 327.
Rule Two: "Ensure...a sufficiently large margin of safety."
Keynes rejected the idea of precisely determining a stock's value. He believed in safeguarding capital and argued that relying on precise valuations, supported by spreadsheets and graphs, distracts investors from understanding the inherent risks of a stock. While such valuations may work well for bonds, they are considered unreliable in the volatile world of stocks. Instead of focusing on precise numbers, Keynes suggested analyzing a company's underlying assets to gauge its value. This approach was simpler in his time when physical assets were predominant on balance sheets. However, with the prevalence of intangible assets like brand equity and patents today, determining underlying value has become more complex. This analysis helps investors incorporate a wide margin of error into their stock valuations, providing reassurance in uncertain market conditions.

Value Investing Strategies
n addition to assessing the value of assets, value investors carefully consider worst-case scenarios, ensuring that a negative turn won't deplete their capital. In the 1930s, public utilities were seen as low-risk investments, with regulations ensuring steady profits. Keynes invested in these utilities, noting that their "monopoly privileges" guaranteed their returns, and his 1933 bet led him to triple his wealth in just a year. Similarly, Buffett saw potential in the Washington Post's near-monopoly in the US capital, investing when its 1974 value was $80 million, despite its assets being worth much more. By avoiding risky tech investments in the late 1990s and sticking with established companies like Coca-Cola, Buffett preserved his capital. Value investors typically seek businesses with low price-to-earnings and price-to-book ratios, coupled with a competitive advantage that provides pricing power or market dominance.

Rule Three: "Apply independent judgment in valuing stocks."
Keynes defied conventional wisdom, advocating "leaning into the wind." He and Buffett believed in being "greedy when others are fearful, and fearful when others are greedy." Despite efficient market theory, they found success in recognizing stock value deviations. Buffett saw this during the internet bubble when Berkshire Hathaway's price fell as the Nasdaq peaked, emphasizing vigilance in investments.
Keynes and Buffett made risky bets that didn't pay off. In 1914, Keynes invested heavily in mining and transportation stocks, believing Europe would avoid war. But he was wrong. Similarly, Buffett misjudged when he bought Berkshire Hathaway, a men's suit lining maker, overlooking its lack of pricing power. These examples highlight the risks of contrarian plays. However, in the long term, value stocks often outperform growth stocks. The key is finding undervalued companies with consistent earnings potential.

Rule Four: "Maintain a steadfast holding of stocks."

Keynes was worried that trading too much and obsessing over stock prices would mess up markets and make investors lose money. He thought it was smart to ignore all the noise and stay calm, even if other investors were acting crazy. He believed that sometimes not doing anything was the best way to make money. In 1938, he talked about his strategy of holding onto investments no matter what, even though he had joked before about nobody living forever. His idea was to stay quiet when everyone else was making noise, focusing on the long term instead of short-term ups and downs. Both Keynes and Buffett warned against investment managers who push you to trade a lot just to make themselves richer. Buffett once joked, "Never ask the barber if you need a haircut." They also pointed out that if you keep buying and selling stocks, you'll end up paying a lot in taxes. Value investors, like Buffett, think it's better to buy and hold onto stocks for a long time. They believe in always keeping an eye on their investments and checking if the reasons they bought each stock still make sense.

Rule Five: "Practice...portfolio concentration."
While diversification is widely advocated in the market, excessive diversification may not yield optimal results. Keynes and Buffett both favored a concentrated portfolio of "ultra favorites" or "superstars" over a large, diversified one. They argue that holding too many stocks dilutes the potential returns and may be better suited for inexperienced investors. Although diversification mitigates downside risk, it also caps upside potential. Keynes and Buffett emphasize that a focused selection of high-quality stocks outperforms a broad portfolio of weaker ones. Moreover, excessive diversification can incentivize speculative behavior, akin to how flood insurance might encourage risky property development near water bodies.

Another common mistake is to "rebalance" a portfolio filled with successful stocks. Buffett compared this to investing in promising basketball players and then selling a star player because they generate too much revenue. Value investors prioritize quality over quantity. Keynes argued for a smaller, less diversified portfolio, believing it to be less risky than a larger one. However, he didn't completely dismiss diversification. He advocated for holding "opposed risks," such as investing in gold to balance out stock holdings.

Rule Six: Balance "equanimity and patience with the ability to act decisively."

After the 1929 crash, many investors lost everything, even taking their own lives. Keynes had a different take on money. He saw it as a tool, not the end goal. He stayed calm and disciplined, knowing he could control his reactions even when the market went wild. Keynes and Buffett understood the importance of sticking to their convictions, even when the market disagreed. They knew that winning stocks didn't bring happiness and losing ones didn't make life worse. Both admitted to holding onto their winners for too long, fueled by their optimism. But they learned from their mistakes, teaching us that successful investing means staying true to your beliefs and keeping your cool amid market madness.

Share:

Latest Books

No Record Found

Related Books

Failed to fetch books

Ratings and Reviews

What do you think about us?

Take a moment to rate and review our app. Your insights help us to improve.

Comment on this Summary

Loading comments...